Decision ·
Win-rate reported, never gated (later: proposal to drop the win-rate conjunct because it is saturated at 0)
From the record
- Context
- Author's direction: research on the Mac mini only until the bar is met; device and claim work after
- Why
- every phone system scores 0 wins vs a 4.9/5 reference
- Reversible
- yes
- Status
- kept
- Alternatives considered
- gate on win-rate > 0
Linked facts · 1
- Win-rate reported, never gated (later: proposal to drop the win-rate conjunct because it is saturated at 0) (why: every phone system scores 0 wins vs a 4.9/5 reference)Win-rate reported, never gated (later: proposal to drop the win-rate conjunct because it is saturated at 0) (why: every phone system scores 0 wins vs a 4.9/5 reference)Date2026-10-10 (BAR-TABLE); plan 2026-10-02 lists W/T/L as a secondary metricKinda record, not a measurement (set, status, judge, n, seeds: not recorded)Caveatthe plan never gated on win-rate, but the deep-tier arm reports of 10-08/09 read the bar as 'floor-adj CI low > 0.50 AND win-rate > 0'; 'reported, never gated' was fixed in BAR-TABLE on 10-10 after RND-REVIEW B1. State bothCheckconflictSourcebenchmark
bench/v0.3/plan/analysis-plan.md:30research recordreports/BAR-TABLE.md:7Open the data file