RatLabA Boar Research
Closed recordas of what’s still open →

Experiment ·

VALIDATION judge

Succinct vs S+ (one 4-5 sentence paragraph) vs two paragraphs

Chapter 14 · Closing the research: what a small model needsadopted

From the record

What was tested
VALIDATION judge (styles)
Result
correctness equal; wrong-unwarned ON 0.12→0.23/0.25
Verdict
adopted: shipped or recommended by its frozen rule
Detail
Succinct stays
Set
UXMATRIX 60
Judge
Claude Haiku 478
Pre-registered
yes (addendum 5)

Linked facts · 1

  • VALIDATION judge (styles): Succinct vs S+ (one 4-5 sentence paragraph) vs two paragraphsVALIDATION judge (styles): Succinct vs S+ (one 4-5 sentence paragraph) vs two paragraphscorrectness equal; wrong-unwarned ON 0.12→0.23/0.25SetUXMATRIX 60JudgeClaude Haiku 478Date2026-10-24Kinda record, not a measurement (status, n, seeds: not recorded)Caveatcriterion frozen: yes (addendum 5); arm verdict: Succinct staysSourcenot in the public repositories yetOpen the data file